Lesbian Riot at Smith College!

Pundits may disagree with his claims, but not more than Smith College activists, who stormed Sorba's lecture and forced him off stage after 20 minutes. The queer Smithies clapped, stomped, screamed, and yelped till Sorba was silenced.

Ryan Sorba, a psychology student and author, is in the process of publishing and promoting his upcoming book "The Born Gay Hoax." The title of the book is pretty self-explanatory, Sorba seeks to discredit the idea of homosexuals being "born that way."

The queer college community has been up in arms about Sorba's brazen campus tour promoting his ideas; queer blogs are teeming with angry posts and comments. An Oasis Journal blogger writes:

"Ryan Sorba: unintelligble, plagiarizing bigot with a mission to make the "born gay hoax" a political phrase by introducing his hate-filled criticism of the gay rights movement across college campuses. Invited by the Smith Republicans, allowed and advertised by the administration."

Some "Smithies" were ashamed of the actions of their peers, as displayed by this Pam's House Blend post:

"As a Smithie who didn't attend Sorba's speech and didn't otherwise loudly protest, I'm extremely frustrated with the people who did. Many of them came back with stories of how fun it was, how great it felt to be so loud and obnoxious that Sorba had to sit down.

That kind of behavior makes coming to Smith worthwhile for Sorba. He must know that most of Smith disagrees with him, so he can't have come here looking to gather support. He clearly doesn't care much for logical argument, so he can't have come here looking to educate us or to start an intelligent debate.

The best thing Sorba could possibly have hoped for in coming to Smith was to raise a ruckus that would bring him publicity for his book. And what did my supposedly intelligent, politically aware, queer-friendly peers do? They gave him exactly what he wanted.

I'm a queer Smithie. I felt attacked by Sorba's presence on my campus. But the behavior of other Smithies and community members who went to the talk? That makes me feel betrayed. "


The campus conservatives are crying foul on this one. The Smith Republican Club contends that the campus is a safe space for queers, but not for Republicans on campus. In this case, I think the Smith queers were a bit too harsh on Sorba. Also, there's a little something called free speech -- no matter how acerbic the claims are, Sorba still has a right to say them.








Advertisement

Comments

Anonymous
Here is the problem. I have known Ryan Sorba for a long time. Sorba is not interested in dialogue or truth (although he loves "debating" anyone). He will use non-academic arguments, outdated anf aulty research, etc. The problem is that the college invited a non-expert. That is academically wrong. Is it right to allow a non-expert to come on campus and spout a bunch of crap? If he was a legit researcher, this would be different. This is hate stuff pure and simple! If the college elevates him to a certain status that he does not deserve, what alternative is there? You can't discuss anything with Ryan (he would post crap like 90% of gay men eat fecal matter on posters around our campus).

Ryan's only goal is to be a subpar Ann Coulter character.
Posted 05/10/2008 8:51 PMReply
Anonymous
From what I know the smith Republican club invited him to the campus to hear his opinion, so basicly the protesters were being rude to their fellow students, who wanted to hear what he had to say. Posted 05/19/2008 3:20 PMReply

Leave a comment


Please enter the text you see below or login to post with a username.