The Top 10 Oddest College Rivalry Trophies

The Top 10 Oddest College Rivalry Trophies
The Milk Can (Photo credit: The Idaho Statesman)The Telephone TrophyThe Golden Egg (Photo credit: AP Photo)Paul Bunyan's Axe

Everyone knows college sports is full of rivalries.

 

But what are these teams actually fighting over?

 

You'd be surprised.

 

Here is OTR's list of the Top 10 Oddest Rivalry Trophies:

 

10. Florida vs. Miami: War Canoe
 

Celebrating the traditions of the Seminole Indians, the War Canoe is hand carved and painted from a 200-year-old tree felled by lightning. Today, though, it resides at UM’s Sports Hall of Fame on campus.

 

9. Mississippi vs. Mississippi State: The Golden Egg Trophy
 

In the 1920s, the rivalry between the two Mississippi schools became so fierce that rioting would break out and the goalposts attacked. To lessen the violence, the Golden Egg trophy was created. The prize was actually a depiction of a football, but back then the footballs looked more like eggs than today.
 

8. Oregon vs. Oregon State: The Platypus Trophy


In the rivalry known as the Civil War, a wooden platypus was given to the winner But in the 60s, the creature went missing but was found recently. It remains to be seen whether the statue will once again grace the trophy shelf of the winner.
 

7. Indiana vs. Michigan State: The Old Brass Spittoon
 

The Old Brass Spittoon tradition started in 1950 but legend has it the spittoon has been around since both universities were first started.

 

6. Cincinnati vs. Louisville: The Keg of Nails
 

Not quite what it sounds like to college guys today, the Keg of Nails trophy is actually a replica of a keg used to ship nails, not to hold beer. The origin, though, is somewhat unclear.

 

5. Michigan State vs. Penn State: The Land Grant Trophy
 

In an odd case of history meeting sports, this trophy’s name honors the Morrill Land Grant Act. The bill used the sale of public land to develop schools of agriculture, and both Michigan State and Penn State are land-grant universities.

 

4. Bowling Green vs. Toledo: The Peace Pipe
 

The peace pipe came into existence in 1947 after 12 years of the two teams not playing each other thanks to fan rioting. The smoking of the pipe was a gesture of goodwill and then used as a trophy for the game.

 

3. Iowa State vs. Missouri: Telephone Trophy
 

During the rival’s game in 1959 it was discovered that the coaches’ field phones were malfunctioning and each team could hear the other. The problem was fixed by the start of the game, but the Northwestern Bell Telephone Co. created the trophy after the controversy and it is still used today.
 

2. Minnesota vs. Wisonsin: Slab of Bacon and now Paul Bunyan’s Axe
 

Before there was Paul Bunyan’s Axe there was the Slab of Bacon, created by Dr. R.B. Fouch who made it to symbolize the winning team “bringing home the bacon.” When the wooden piece of meat went missing, the equally strange Paul Bunyan’s Axe was instituted.

 

1. Fresno State vs. Boise State: The Milk Can
 

The Milk Can, a chromed, 10-gallon, old-school milk can is a fairly new trophy, started in 2005. The Dairymen in Fresno and Boise thought up the trophy to make the rivalry official and, of course, shamelessly promote the benefits of milk.

 

 

 

+ 10 comments

Related Posts

Comments

Anonymous
What about the bronzed rack of ribs played for by UAB & Memphis Posted 08/26/2008 12:48 PMReply
Anonymous
that picture looks like someone made a trophy out of handbanana (aqua teens reference) Posted 08/26/2008 2:33 PMReply
Anonymous
This is the most stupid list ever, they did not even include the oldest trophy of all, "The Little Brown Jug", dated back to 1902 between Michigan and Minnesota. Posted 08/26/2008 3:49 PMReply
Anonymous
Oaken Bucket for the Indiana and Purdue game. Posted 08/26/2008 3:52 PMReply
Anonymous
Uh, dudes, I don't think the point was to list oldest trophies, just the *oddest* ones. Please don't tell me an institution of higher learning has accepted you into its student body. If so, I think the value of my undergrad degree may have dropped a couple of points.

I digress.

No Illibuck trophy?
Posted 08/27/2008 09:41 AMReply
Anonymous
So, considering that the trophy is now in the UM Sports Hall of Fame, does that mean that UF and UM are not playing for it this year? I hope they do, that thing is gonna look great here in Gainesville. Ha! A trophy that was made by the Seminoles, won by the Gators, off of the Hurricanes. I love football. Posted 08/27/2008 3:55 PMReply
Anonymous
Actually it IS about the oldest rivalry trophies. can you not read the title of the list? Posted 08/28/2008 12:55 AMReply
teej
@ Anonymous: except it says "Oddest" not "oldest". notice the second D, not an L? Posted 08/28/2008 01:20 AMReply
Anonymous
illibuck, it's a freakin wooden turtle Posted 08/28/2008 3:04 PMReply
Anonymous
How about the Cortaca Jug? Cortland vs. Ithaca, every year. Posted 08/29/2008 12:13 PMReply

Add a comment

Anonymous comment

Please enter the code or log in.

Facebook Comment