Volunteers searching for missing Middlebury College freshman Nicholas Garza discovered smiley face graffiti close to a nearby river. Police say the face has been there for years, but Garza's mother is unconvinced. Last week, someone found a smiley face painted on a tree near the Hudson River where Joshua Szostak was discovered "accidentally" dro

MORE »

Across Wisconsin, Minnesota, Illinois, Ohio, Pennsylvania, Indiana, Iowa, it's the same every time: the guys are at a party or a bar getting hammered, maybe with a girl or friends, and then they're gone. A few days later, they're found in a river or a lake, and the symbol of a smiley face is found nearby...

Now-retired NYPD detectives Kevin Ga

MORE »