Islamophobic Ad Printed in Penn State Newspaper

Islamophobic Ad Printed in Penn State Newspaper
Quite frankly I'm pretty shocked that there hasn't been more coverage of this. On Monday, The Collegian ran an ad from conservative nutjob David Horowitz which called Penn State's Muslim Student Association (MSA) a "front group for jihad." Strong words, but it's typical of Horowitz who sponsored the "Islamo-Fascism Awareness Week" last semester which brought Rick Santorum to campus. Well now, three days later we hear the MSA's response.

In addition to a letter which was sent to The Collegian (and can be seen here) from Judy Bowes, the MSA's PR officer, a Facebook group (of course) entitled "Petition to stop Racist and Islamaphobic Collegian Hate Advertisments" (sic) has been set up and as of 6:30 Thursday had 450 members.

Part of the MSA's argument is that under the policies on The Collegian's rate card it states: "Collegian Inc. reserves the right to refuse or to change advertising ... that maligns identifiable persons, races, religions or professions." In the letter to The Collegian, Bowes also says she feels the paper's decision to run the ad "was made hastily." But Collegian Business Manager Carolyn Yanoff says she sat on the ad for two weeks waiting for documentation from Horowitz' office.

I didn't see the ad on Monday, but it appears to be a half-page ad, which according to The Collegian's rate card, goes for $705.60. The MSA is asking that The Collegian "donate at least one page in the newspaper to the Muslim Student Association to use as they wish," as well as an apology from The Collegian for running the ad.

Well, if that's what the MSA is really looking for they probably shouldn't hold their breath. They're not going to apologize because technically they did nothing wrong in running the ad. I would assume that this exact ad has been run in other colleges across the country and it's probably carefully worded as to fit under the guidelines. And when was the last time you saw a newspaper apologize for anything?

So if the MSA wants to do something about it, gather together $705.60 (that's $1.50 from each of the members of your Facebook group) and buy an ad. But guess what, there's only six more Collegians left this semester, so you better act quickly.
+ 4 comments

Related Posts

Comments

Anonymous
I noticed that the other day and was wondering when people were going to freak out. I'm not Muslim, but I was pretty shocked at the "islamophobia" present in the ad.
P.S. Rick Santorum is a douche... yay Murphy!
Posted 04/24/2008 4:54 PMReply
Anonymous
I am in the MSA. I want to laugh at Horowitz because he really is a nutjob, but then again, his words are extremely threatening and may have serious repercussions. He claims that he is only trying to increase dialog (but that's such an old excuse, and lacking in action). By the way, Young Americans for Freedom, the group who brought santorum, sabotaged another event of ours with PSU Libertarians because we spoke out against Santorum's inability to even get Muslim history straight during his speech. This is no longer about engaging in civil dialog and fighting terrorism, it's about hating Muslims in general. That's evident from the ad. Posted 04/25/2008 07:14 AMReply
Anonymous
If MSA really does have really bad roots, shouldn't Muslims who reject the Muslim Brotherhood simply start up a different club? Just like YAF should be held responsible for Ann Coulter's ramblings, shouldn't MSA be held accountable for its speakers? I don't really see how the ad is threatening. It doesn't call for violence against Muslims, or even criticize Islam- it criticizes the Muslim Brotherhood. Are any of the criticisms (besides the debatable characterization of motives) factually false? I doubt seriously that every member of MSA has even thought about the organization's roots. I guarantee that now they will. Posted 04/25/2008 09:58 AMReply
Anonymous
@ Anonymous: @ Anonymous:

I see you didn't refute any of Horowitz's claims in the ad, though, you simply made an attack on Horowitz.
Posted 08/06/2008 2:11 PMReply

Add a comment

Anonymous comment

Please enter the code or log in.

Facebook Comment